Sight & Sound: May 2013

Cover of Sight & Sound May 2013The latest Sight & Sound is out, complete with the following pieces by me:

  • How We Won The War (p. 35) – an overview of Soviet and Russian cinema’s treatment of the Great Patriotic War, aka World War II;
  • White Elephant (p. 109) – review of Pablo Trapero’s well-intentioned, well-staged but slightly disappointing seventh feature (at least by the standards he’s previously set himself);
  • Baise-Moi (p. 112) – review of Arrow’s knockout edition of Virginie Despentes and Coralie Trinh Thi’s problematic rape-revenge film, the first DVD version to be both uncut and framed correctly;
  • City of Women (p. 115) – review of Masters of Cinema’s superb Blu-ray and DVD editions of what I now regard as Federico Fellini’s last great film: I was rather more impressed by it this time round than when I first caught it in Paris in the early 1990s, although English subtitles certainly would have helped;
  • The Murderer Lives At 21 (p. 115) – review of Masters of Cinema’s Blu-ray and DVD editions of suspense master Henri-Georges Clouzot’s deceptively lighthearted directorial debut – given the film’s obscurity and the fact that it’s a whodunit at base, I decided to avoid narrative spoilers, which meant that I had to soft-pedal one of the film’s key themes.

Polish Cinema Classics Volume II

DVD cover for Polish Cinema ClassicsAlmost a year to the day after Second Run released its first collection of Polish Cinema Classics, they brought out a second volume. Whereas the first consisted of four films from Polish cinema’s first golden era (the late 50s/early 60s), this triple-bills three very different films whose only real point in common is their creative excellence and the reputation of their makers – at least at home. (In the UK, Wojciech Marczewski is all but unknown compared with Andrzej Wajda and Krzysztof Zanussi, but that has far more to do with lack of access than lack of merit.) Second Run also pulled off a genuine coup in securing the world DVD premiere of the original theatrical cut of Wajda’s The Promised Land (Ziemia obiecana, 1974), previously only available on DVD in the director’s contentiously truncated 2000 cut or the four-part TV edit from 1978. Zanussi’s Illumination (Iluminacja, 1972) and Marczewski’s Escape from the ‘Liberty’ Cinema (Ucieczka z kina ‘Wolność’) are both available in Poland, but in transfers ranging from adequate to terrible, whereas all three films here have benefited from the same kind of wholesale digital restorations that fuelled Second Run’s first box – director-approved in all three cases.

DVD cover for Escape from the 'Liberty' CinemaI wrote the booklet for Escape from the ‘Liberty’ Cinema, which also gave me an excellent opportunity to delve into the rest of Wojciech Marczewski’s hugely impressive back catalogue. I uncovered a surprising amount of it, including his early TV movies Easter (Wielkanoc, 1974), Whiter Than Snow (Bielszy niż śnieg, 1975) and The Steward (Klucznik, 1979), plus his first two cinema features, Nightmares (Zmory, 1978) and Shivers (Dreszcze, 1981) – the latter in particular, with its semi-autobiographical portrait of a summer at a Stalinist holiday camp (!) would make a brilliant Second Run release in its own right, and apparently it was a toss-up between that and Escape from the ‘Liberty’ Cinema. But I can see why they picked the latter: its portrait of a jaded provincial censor trying to deal with the cast of a completed film rebelling against its banal and compromised story and dialogue (in a medium-bending conceit consciously lifted from Woody Allen’s The Purple Rose of Cairo) is much more accessible and its are concerns far more universal.

Unsurprisingly for someone so little known outside Poland, there was a distinct paucity of material on Marczewski to draw on, but the booklet for the Polish box set of his first three features included some useful interviews, and I also managed to track down a copy of the only book about his work (Andrzej Szpulak’s Filmy Wojciecha Marczewskiego, 2009), which included an entire chapter on ‘Liberty’ Cinema – it was much more analytical than factual, and I’d already written the bulk of my booklet essay when the book arrived, but it had a few exploitable nuggets.

Sight & Sound: January 2013

Cover of Sight & Sound January 2013The latest Sight & Sound is out, complete with the following pieces by me:

  • The Joy of Six (p. 97) – review of a generally pretty successful compilation of half a dozen new British short films;
  • McCullin (p. 101) – review of the excellent, thorough documentary about the great war photographer Don McCullin;
  • Films by Victor Erice (p. 114) – specifically, his first two features Spirit of the Beehive and South, both released on gratifyingly cheap and even more gratifyingly English-friendly Spanish Blu-ray discs;
  • Gate of Hell (p. 116) – review of Masters of Cinema’s immaculate presentation of Teinosuke Kinugasa’s Eastmancolor showcase, an eye-popping visual treat that’s nonetheless a notch below the best mid-Fifties Japanese period dramas;
  • Films by Kim Ki-duk (p. 116) – specifically his debut Crocodile (1996) and his recent Arirang (2011), a surprisingly apposite double bill given the latter’s back-to-basics return to his improvised roots;
  • This Is Cinerama (p. 120) – review of Flicker Alley’s surprisingly effective Blu-ray treatment of the ginormous-screen classic. Obviously, it can’t possibly replicate an authentic Cinerama experience at home, but the plethora of extras is a historian’s dream.

Mother Joan of the Angels

DVD cover for Mother Joan of the AngelsBack in 2005, one of Second Run’s very first releases was Jerzy Kawalerowicz’s Mother Joan of the Angels (Matka Joanna od aniołów, 1961). Back then, the label had a guiding philosophy that it was more important to get a particular film out there in an English-friendly edition than it was to secure the best possible source, and so the fact that it was only available in a clearly elderly analogue tape master wasn’t considered a major drawback. The grey and smeary end result was, frankly, VHS quality, but the excellence of the film itself meant that it got surprisingly sympathetic reviews, thus vindicating their strategy at the time.

Jump forward nearly seven years, and the film finally underwent a state-of-the-art high-definition digital restoration, with the involvement of cinematographer Jerzy Wójcik. Although they’d never reissued one of their back-catalogue titles before, the improvements were too dramatic to ignore, as was the fact that this new version had only been released in Poland on an unsubtitled DVD (which came out about a year ago). Hence this revamped reissue – and they also took the opportunity to beef up the package as a whole, by replacing the original skimpy booklet essay with a far more substantial piece by David Sorfa and a slightly rewritten version of the Kawalerowicz biography that I originally wrote for Night Train (in the Polish Cinema Classics box). They also changed the cover artwork, reflecting their current preference for much more stylised treatments:

DVD covers for Mother Joan of the Angels

On top of all that, they asked me if I’d record my second 20-minute video appreciation for them, which was filmed in the afternoon of March 11 (I can be very precise about the date, because I hosted a Q&A with actor Robert Więckiewicz that evening), but I had to keep schtum about it until the release was formally announced. This was pretty straightforward – unlike the first time round, I knew in advance what the setup would be, and that I’d have to talk directly to the camera without notes, and we got the whole thing in the can in less than an hour.

My biggest problem during recording was a repeated inability to pronounce the character name ‘Chrząszczewski’ correctly (I’ve forgotten how many takes that one needed!), but I’m reasonably happy with how it came out. I have two complaints, one of which is completely my fault (at the very start, I left out the month from the film’s opening date), the other of which was an ill-advised edit (removing an explanation about the difference between the French town of Loudun, where the original alleged possessions took place, and the Polish town of Ludyń, where the events were relocated, thus making a later and uncontextualised reference to Ludyń sound like a straightforward case of mispronunciation), but I daresay I’m the only one who noticed.

Polish Cinema Classics

DVD cover for Polish Cinema ClassicsSecond Run’s latest box set is out today, but while its predecessors simply repackaged older single-disc releases in a more attractively-priced collection, this one contains brand new releases in the form of four Polish films from the turn of the 1960s that have long achieved classic status at home but which are still comparatively little known in Britain: Andrzej Munk’s Eroica (1958), Andrzej Wajda’s Innocent Sorcerers (Niewinni czarodzieje, 1960), Jerzy Kawalerowicz’s Night Train (Pociąg, 1959) and Janusz Morgenstern’s Goodbye, See You Tomorrow (Do widzenia, do jutra, 1960), all taking advantage of new high-definition digital restorations commissioned by the newly reconstituted Studio Kadr and supervised by the films directors and/or cinematographers, if still alive. I wrote the booklets for the last two titles, which presented different challenges.

DVD cover for Night TrainNight Train was the most straightforward: I’d written a thousand-word piece about it in the past, so recycled bits of that, and added a more detailed character study (in which I had to devise names for many of the train’s passengers, as they’re not given in the actual film) and a biography of Kawalerowicz. The latter gave me an excuse to watch as many of his films as I could track down: this was easier with the 1950s and 60s titles (I saw everything from 1953′s Cellulose/Celuloza to 1966′s Pharaoh/Faraon) than it was for many of the later ones – I don’t think I’ve ever had the chance to see his Italian film Maddalena (1971), a film that’s best known for its Ennio Morricone score (although far more people know it as the theme to the BBC series The Life and Times of David Lloyd George), although I was able to see Death of a President/Śmierć prezydenta (1977) and Austeria (1982).

DVD cover for Goodbye See You TomorrowGoodbye, See You Tomorrow was markedly tougher given the comparative lack of research material in English. A major godsend for background material was the booklet in Best Film Co’s 50 Years of the Polish Film School box set, whose essay by Marek Hendrykowski provided a fair amount of detail, as did a comparative study of this film and Three Colours: White by Elzieta Ostrowska and Joanna Rydzewska. A chance discovery of Kathleen M. Cioffi’s book Alternative Theatre in Poland 1954-1989 provided essential background on the experimental theatre scene that fuelled Zbigniew Cybulski’s original script and his approach to realising it onscreen. I also found a long interview with director Janusz Morgenstern in Gazeta Wyborcza, which provided useful biographical info (unlike the situation with Kawalerowicz, most of Morgenstern’s films aren’t easily viewable, even on unsubtitled video copies). Almost at the last minute, I realised that this would be a heaven-sent opportunity to quote from Alexei Sayle’s hilarious memoir Stalin Ate My Homework, specifically the bit where he decides to use Cybulski as a role model, with disastrous consequences.

Sight & Sound: October 2011

Cover of Sight & Sound October 2011The latest Sight & Sound is out, complete with the following pieces by me:

  • Out of sight, out of mind (p. 27) – a brief history of the production and suppression Ken Loach’s notoriously polemical documentary for the Save the Children Fund, given its public world premiere on September 1 after being shelved for forty years;
  • Page One: Inside the New York Times (p. 72) – review of Andrew Rossi’s access-all-areas documentary about the venerable American broadsheet newspaper at a time of crisis for traditional media;
  • Before the Revolution (p. 84) – review of the BFI’s dual-format edition of Bernardo Bertolucci’s dazzlingly precocious second feature;
  • The Colour of Pomegranates (p. 84) – review of the Second Sight DVD, which finally does the film justice after several near-misses;
  • Father (p. 85) – review of Second Run’s excellent DVD of István Szabó’s coruscating second feature, a milestone of 1960s Hungarian filmmaking;
  • The Garden of the Finzi-Contini (p. 85) – review of the latest Arrow Academy release, a DVD-only edition of Vittorio de Sica’s final Oscar-winner. Presumably the poor quality of the transfer explains the lack of the usual Blu-ray: a shame, as the package is otherwise excellent;
  • The Music Room (p. 86) – Satyajit Ray’s masterly fourth feature given the deluxe Criterion treatment;
  • Schloss Vogelöd (p. 89) – review of Masters of Cinema’s DVD of F.W. Murnau’s oldest surviving feature, also (misleadingly) known as The Haunted Castle.

Sight & Sound: September 2011

Cover of Sight & Sound September 2011The latest Sight & Sound is out, complete with the following pieces by me:

  • The Interrupters (p. 52) – this month’s Film of the Month, a sobering documentary study by the maker of Hoop Dreams of Chicago street violence and a promising initiative aimed at dealing with it;
  • Carmen (p. 83) – review of the DVD (sadly, I wasn’t sent the Blu-ray) of Second Sight’s restored edition of Francesco Rosi’s 1984 opera-film;
  • Cœur fidèle (p. 83) – review of Masters of Cinema’s first Jean Epstein release, a demonstration-quality silent film Blu-ray;
  • Pigs & Battleships/Stolen Desire (p. 87) – review of another Masters of Cinema package, this time devoted to Shohei Imamura’s first and fifth features;
  • They Went Into Space (p. 88) – review of Telewizja Kinopolska’s sci-fi collection (‘Pojechane w kosmos’), containing the DEFA co-productions The Silent Star and Signals: An Adventure in Space, the Stanisław Lem adaptation Pirx’s Test Flight and the hilarious Indiana Jones ripoff The Curse of Snake Valley. The latter may well be the silliest film I’ve reviewed for S&S to date.

Szindbád review roundup

DVD cover for SzindbádSecond Run’s DVD edition of Zoltán Huszárik’s masterpiece Szindbád comes out today, and reviews have generally been ecstatic.

These ones are less keen on the film, but are nice about the extras:

…and here’s Second Run’s own page about the film and the DVD.

Sight & Sound: August 2011

Cover of Sight & Sound August 2011The latest Sight & Sound is out, complete with the following pieces by me:

  • Faccia a faccia (p. 85) – review of Eureka’s new DVD of Sergio Sollima’s underrated Italian western, released uncut for the first time in Britain;
  • The Halfway House (p. 86) – review of Optimum’s excellent DVD restoration of Ealing Studios’ J.B. Priestley-like wartime ghost story;
  • The Kremlin Letter (p. 86) – review of Eureka’s DVD of John Huston’s fantastically downbeat Cold War drama about disillusioned spies;
  • Rififi (p. 89) – review of the Arrow Academy edition of the classic heist thriller, complete with one of the best black-and-white pictures yet seen on a Blu-ray;
  • The Kingdom I & II (p. 91) – review of the superb new Second Sight edition of Lars von Trier and Morton Arnfred’s gleefully unhinged hospital soap opera.

Szindbád

DVD cover for SzindbádA test pressing of Second Run’s Szindbád arrived in the post, allowing me to confirm a few things about the final release (currently scheduled for 11 July – Amazon/MovieMail/Play).

1. It’s definitely a fresh anamorphic transfer, not an upscale of the old letterboxed Mokép DVD. A side-by-side comparison reveals noticeably more detail on the Second Run version.

2. Even though I can’t judge the accuracy of the translation, I can confirm that the subtitles are a clear improvement on Mokép’s, both in terms of filling in previously untranslated gaps in the dialogue, and in subtitling onscreen text (which the Mokép disc didn’t do).

3. Although there were rumours that Zoltán Huszárik’s breakthrough short Elégia would be included on Second Run’s disc (as it is on the Mokép one), it seems that a last-minute and wholly unexpected rights complication meant that it had to be dropped.

4. So the only video extra is one of Second Run’s “personal appreciations”, this time by Peter Strickland, the director of Katalin Varga. To my surprise, he opens by crediting me with his discovery of the film in the first place (it was my contribution to Sight & Sound‘s “75 hidden gems” feature of summer 2007), so I should probably acknowledge that Stefan Kuhn was the man responsible for drawing my attention to it a few months earlier when he sent me the Mokép DVD. It was fascinating seeing Peter visibly wrestling with the same issues that I had with the booklet (see below) – namely, how do you put into words what you feel about such a supremely visual and aural experience?

5. The other extra is a 20-page booklet, which I haven’t seen yet, but I suspect it’s mostly devoted to the 6,000 word essay I wrote about the film, its literary origins and its director. To put it mildly, this was one of my more challenging recent commissions – I agreed to do it without hesitation because I loved the film, but even aside from the difficulty of conveying its pleasures in verbal form, background research was stymied by the lack of much of any substance available in English, or indeed any other language besides Hungarian. Thankfully, Google Translate was my friend (though I was very careful indeed to source factual claims from more than one document), and various back issues of the Hungarofilm Bulletin (produced by the Hungarian Communist authorities five times yearly to promote their national cinema to English speakers) supplied interviews and other useful background. I also drew on George Szirtes’ translation of some of the original Gyula Krúdy short stories (published as The Adventures of Sindbad), and a New Yorker piece on Krúdy by the Hungarian critic John Lukacs).

Oh, and here’s an enlargement of the cover:

DVD cover of Szindbád

I’ve been a fan of Second Run’s artwork more or less since the label was launched (you can see the lot here, and I singled out personal favourites in this Kinoblog post), but I really think they’ve excelled themselves with this. It was no small challenge summing up this gorgeously-shot but deliberately slippery and elusive film in a single image (the Hungarian DVD opted for the film’s original poster), but they’ve done a blinding job here, conveying the sense of fading memories, the way they’re triggered by Proustian associations with objects, the film’s literary source and Szindbád’s obsession with the opposite sex.